Cardano’s Charles Hoskinson Clashes With Blockstream’s Adam Back Over Crypto Security Classification

Charles Hoskinson Expresses Frustration Over Cardano's Security Classification

Charles Hoskinson, co-founder of Input Output Global (IOHK) and the Cardano blockchain initiative, recently expressed his frustration in a video over the U.S. regulator's decision to categorize the cryptocurrency cardano as a security. He is perplexed and critical about the exemption of bitcoin from being tagged as a security, mocking the situation as a "pathetic joke" and pointing out the apparent free pass granted to "Team Orange."

Hoskinson Questions Inconsistencies in Regulatory Approach

In a video clip shared by Altcoin Daily on a social media platform referred to as X, Charles Hoskinson passionately discussed his views on cardano's (ADA) classification as a security, contrasting it with bitcoin (BTC) and others in the crypto space. He questions the logic, highlighting what he perceives as inconsistencies and unfair treatment in the regulatory approach.

Hoskinson questions the absence of expectation of profit among fervent bitcoin supporters, known as the "Orange pill moon boys." He criticizes the perceived decentralization of Bitcoin, noting that subpoenaing or targeting a few entities could potentially lead to a 51% attack on the network due to the nature of its hashpower distribution. He lambasts this oversight as a glaring, "pathetic f***ing joke."

Response from Adam Back

Following the video's release by Altcoin Daily, users of platform X reacted to Hoskinson's assertions. In a thread on X, Blockstream founder Adam Back responded, tagging Hoskinson. Back simplified the distinction, stating, "[Charles Hoskinson] it's very simple: Bitcoin did not do an ICO, most people thought it had no value, it was mined from zero, it is decentralized, there is no CEO, ICO warchested 'foundation,' incorporation etc. so Cardano, ETH etc clearly pass Howey, Bitcoin is a commodity and does not."

Cardano's ICO Explanation

Responding to Back, Hoskinson clarified that Cardano didn't have an ICO. Instead, he detailed an airdrop and subsequent trading of ADA by a diverse group of individuals who also used the platform for various projects.

He further elaborated:

"A voucher sale of a different asset outside of the United States, priced in Yen, settled in Bitcoin, explained in Japanese to Japanese citizens, and without a single U.S. participant does not constitute an ICO of ADA."

As per Cardano's Genesis records, these ADA token vouchers were distributed through sales in Asia from October 2015 to early January 2017. A Japanese company facilitated these sales, which garnered 108,844.5 BTC. The debate continued with Back countering Hoskinson's explanation, suggesting that an airdrop, premine, and some market activity still classify as an ICO. He also pointed to the reliance on a management team for profit expectations.

Hoskinson's Frustration with Bitcoin Advocates

Hoskinson refuted the notion that an airdrop equates to an initial coin offering (ICO), citing even the SEC's ambiguity on the matter. He pointed to the SEC's settlement with EOS and as a case in point. Hoskinson emphasized that ADA was not publicly offered by a centralized entity, contrasting it with Ethereum's ICO for ether, which has not been classified as a security.

Expressing his frustration, Hoskinson criticized the bitcoin community for labeling non-Bitcoin projects as inferior or fraudulent. He condemned what he perceived as efforts by Bitcoin advocates to push U.S. authorities to outlaw cryptocurrencies other than Bitcoin. He also dismissed the argument that Bitcoin's mining process was fundamentally different, noting that Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin's creator, initially had complete control over the network and remained anonymous due to legal uncertainties.

Back's Comparison of Bitcoin with Gold and Diamonds

The Blockstream executive responded by comparing bitcoin with gold and diamonds, arguing that none of these are securities. Despite claims that gold prices are influenced by sovereign entities and diamond prices by companies like Debeers, Back asserted that they, like bitcoin, are commodities. He maintained that ether, ADA, and similar cryptocurrencies are, in contrast, securities. Furthermore, he emphasized that these assets are "both unregistered, and unregisterable securities too."

What do you think about the debate between Charles Hoskinson and Adam Back? Share your thoughts and opinions about this subject in the comments section below.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is buying gold a good retirement plan?

Although it may not look appealing at first, buying gold for investment is worth considering when you consider the global average gold consumption per year.

Physical bullion bar is the best way to invest in precious metals. You can also invest in gold in other ways. It's best to thoroughly research all options before you make a decision.

If you don't want to keep your wealth safe, buying shares in companies that extract gold and mining equipment could be a better choice. If you are looking for cash flow from your investment, buying gold stocks will work well.

You can also invest your money in exchange-traded fund (ETFs), which give you exposure to the gold price by holding securities related to gold. These ETFs can include stocks of precious metals refiners and gold miners.

What Should Your IRA Include in Precious Metals?

You should remember that precious metals are not only for the wealthy. It doesn't matter how rich you are to invest in precious metals. In fact, there are many ways to make money from gold and silver investments without spending much money.

You may consider buying physical coins such as bullion bars or rounds. Also, you could buy shares in companies producing precious metals. You might also want to use an IRA rollover program offered through your retirement plan provider.

No matter what your preference, precious metals will still be of benefit to you. These metals are not stocks, but they can still provide long-term growth.

Their prices are more volatile than traditional investments. This means that if you decide on selling your investment later, you'll likely get more profit than you would with traditional investing.

What is a Precious Metal IRA and How Can You Benefit From It?

An IRA with precious metals allows you to diversify retirement savings into gold and silver, palladium, rhodiums, iridiums, osmium, or other rare metals. These precious metals are extremely rare and valuable. They are great investments for your money, and they can protect you from inflation or economic instability.

Bullion is often used to refer to precious metals. Bullion refers actually to the metal.

Bullion can be bought through many channels, including online retailers, large coins dealers, and some grocery shops.

A precious metal IRA allows you to invest directly in bullion, rather than buying stock shares. This allows you to receive dividends every year.

Precious Metal IRAs don’t require paperwork nor have annual fees. You pay only a small percentage of your gains tax. Additionally, you have access to your funds at no cost whenever you need them.

What Precious Metals Can You Invest in for Retirement?

These precious metals are among the most attractive investments. They are both easy to trade and have been around for years. If you want to diversify your portfolio, you should consider adding them to your list.

Gold: One of the oldest forms of currency, gold, is one of mankind's most valuable. It's also very safe and stable. Because of this, it is considered a great way of preserving wealth during times when there are uncertainties.

Silver: Silver is a popular investment choice. It's a great option for those who want stability. Silver tends to move up, not down, unlike gold.

Platinium: Another form of precious metal is platinum, which is becoming more popular. It's like silver or gold in that it is durable and resistant to corrosion. It's however much more costly than any of its counterparts.

Rhodium: Rhodium is used in catalytic converters. It is also used to make jewelry. It is also very affordable in comparison to other types.

Palladium: Palladium, which is a form of platinum, is less common than platinum. It's also less expensive. Investors looking to add precious and rare metals to their portfolios love it for these reasons.


  • (Basically, if your GDP grows by 2%, you need miners to dig 2% more gold out of the ground every year to keep prices steady.) (
  • If you take distributions before hitting 59.5, you'll owe a 10% penalty on the amount withdrawn. (
  • Indeed, several financial advisers interviewed for this article suggest you invest 5 to 15 percent of your portfolio in gold, just in case. (
  • If you accidentally make an improper transaction, the IRS will disallow it and count it as a withdrawal, so you would owe income tax on the item's value and, if you are younger than 59 ½, an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty. (
  • Gold is considered a collectible, and profits from a sale are taxed at a maximum rate of 28 percent. (

External Links

How To

The best place online to buy silver and gold

Before you can buy gold, it is important to understand its workings. Gold is a precious metallic similar to Platinum. It's rare and often used to make money due its resistance and durability to corrosion. It's hard to use, so most people prefer buying jewelry made out of it to actual bars of gold.

There are two types currently available: legal tender and bullion. Legal tender coins are those that are intended for circulation in a country. They typically have denominations of $1, $5 or $10.

Bullion coin are not intended for investment. However, their value will increase with inflation.

They cannot be used in currency exchanges. If a person purchases $100 worth of gold, 100 grams of the gold will be given to him/her. The $100 value is $100. For every dollar spent, the buyer gets 1 gram of Gold.

When you are looking to purchase gold, the next thing to know is where to get it. There are several options available if your goal is to purchase gold from a dealer. First, you can visit your local coin store. You can also try going through a reputable website like eBay. You can also purchase gold through private online sellers.

Individuals who sell gold at wholesale and retail prices are called private sellers. Private sellers typically charge 10% to 15% commission on each transaction. That means you would get back less money from a private seller than from a coin shop or eBay. This option can be a good choice for investing in gold because it allows you to control the price.

Another option for buying gold is to invest in physical gold. Although physical gold is easier to store than paper certificates you will still need to ensure it is safe. To ensure that your physical gold remains safe, you need to secure it in an impenetrable container such as a vault or safety deposit box.

You can either visit a bank, pawnshop or bank to buy gold. A bank can offer you a loan for the amount that you need to buy gold. Pawnshops are small establishments allowing customers to borrow money against items they bring. Banks usually charge higher interest rates that pawn shops.

Finally, another way to buy gold is to simply ask someone else to do it! Selling gold is also easy. Set up a simple account with and you will start receiving payments instantly.

By: Jamie Redman
Title: Cardano’s Charles Hoskinson Clashes With Blockstream’s Adam Back Over Crypto Security Classification
Sourced From:
Published Date: Tue, 28 Nov 2023 14:30:52 +0000

Recent Posts
Latest Featured Posts
Latest News Posts